Medjugorje: Mary or Lying Wonder?
Are the 40,000 plus visions and messages some seers in Medjugorje (in Bosnia Herzegovina) reportedly had since 1981 really from the mother of Jesus, as many believe, or from a lying wonder or simply being made up? The answer to that question would obviously be worth knowing. But let’s assume for a minute that the source of these visions/messages really is Mary or supernatural, the mother of our Lord and Savior. If so, would she lie to you?
I’m going to assume that you said, “No”; Mary, the mother of Jesus wouldn’t lie to me.
And I’m further going to assume that all of real Christianity would also agree with you. Therefore, if what the vision said to the seers in Medjugorje is not true, the vision must be some type of a lying wonder. These are the only two choices.
In order for you and I to know whether or not what the vision told the seers was the truth or a lie, we would have to interview the seers, respectfully question them, and then follow up on what the apparition told them. Well, the Vatican of the Roman Catholic Church has done some of that investigation for us.
Roman Catholic reports concluded that there have been many contradictions and inaccuracies in what the 'Lady of Medjugorje' allegedly told the seers. To be perfectly clear, that doesn’t mean the seers didn’t really see any vision. What it does mean is that whatever they did see was a “lying wonder” or otherwise demonic.
In May of 2017, late Pope Francis specifically stated of the 'Lady of Medjugorje,' "This is not the Mother of Jesus."
In a report involving 15 years of study, the Vatican did not declare the apparitions authentic or of supernatural origin. Nevertheless, the has Vatican concluded that, even though the vision had evidence of being a lying wonder, it would be fine for Roman Catholics to visit and worship at the site, because it claimed the Holy Spirit--which Jesus repeatedly called "the Spirit of Truth" (John 14:17, 15:26. 16:13)--was working there. The Church of Rome officially gave the Medjugorje site a "Nihil Obstat" meaning that it has no objections for pilgrimages there--despite the Vatican concluding that many of the messages were false/contradictions. The Holy Spirit of Truth is NOT involved with these Medjugorje messages mixing "good and evil"!
Jesus says that God is seeking people to worship Him in spirit and truth (John 4:23). You can’t have it both ways by saying something is partially false, but stating that there are no objections to it. Does the Bible have warnings about a 'Lady of the Kingdoms'? Watch this video as Dr. Thiel shines the light of Biblical truth on the truth of God vs lying wonders.
Read the full article to this video titled “Mary has not spoken at Medjugorje, yet Pope Leo XIV appointed a new Vatican envoy to Medjugorje and claims it has ‘spiritual fruits’: Signs and lying wonders!” at URL
https://www.cogwriter.com/news/religious-news/mary-has-not-spoken-at-medjugorje-yet-pope-leo-xiv-appointed-a-new-vatican-envoy-to-medjugorje-and-claims-it-has-spiritual-fruits/
Medjugorje Marian Apparitions, Vatican Deception, and End-Time Lying Wonders with Dr. Bob Thiel
Steve Dupuis asks Dr. Bob Thiel about the Vatican granting approval to the Medjugorje apparitions, and Thiel warns that claimed Marian visions contradict scripture, representing deceptive lying wonders foretold to mislead the world in the end times.
Vatican Approval and the Medjugorje Phenomena
Steve Dupuis opens the broadcast by asking Dr. Bob Thiel about recent news reports concerning Pope Leo the Fourteenth appointing a Vatican envoy to Medjugorje. Thiel explains that the Roman Catholic Church granted the Bosnian site a nihil obstat declaration, signaling no official objection to pilgrimages while claiming the location produces spiritual fruits such as conversions, sacramental participation, and Eucharistic devotion. However, Thiel rejects the assertion that devotion to the Eucharist constitutes genuine spiritual fruit according to the Bible. He references a September 2024 report noting that fifteen years of Vatican analysis failed to verify any supernatural origin, while simultaneously flagging severe contradictions in messages reported by visionaries. Despite these documented inconsistencies and the astonishing claim that Mary appeared more than forty thousand times since 1981, church authorities continue permitting public devotion. Thiel contends that ecclesiastical leadership excuses theological flaws merely because pilgrims display enthusiastic religious behavior.
Contradictory Messages and Compromised Theology
Dupuis asks whether Roman Catholic believers are actively accepting a falsehood. Thiel responds affirmatively, declaring that Jesus's mother Mary is not appearing in Medjugorje or delivering prophecies. Reading from a LifeSiteNews article, Thiel points out that Vatican officials conceded certain messages contain direct contradictions or appear designed to advance the personal financial interests of the seers. Furthermore, the apparition audaciously referred to unfolding events as my plan and my project, language that Thiel warns elevates a created being above divine sovereignty. Most egregiously, when questioned about world religions, the apparition claimed that all faiths are similar before God and that God rules over them all like a sovereign over his kingdom. Thiel stresses that this teaching promotes ecumenical compromise, effectively claiming that a mixture of truth and error remains acceptable. He argues that attributing such unbiblical assertions to the Holy Spirit deceives vulnerable worshippers while obscuring authentic apostolic doctrine.
Papal Skepticism and the Spirit of Truth
Addressing the apparition's claim of religious equivalence, Thiel highlights that Pope Francis made a similarly flawed declaration in 2024 by asserting every religion serves as a path to God. Thiel refutes this ecumenical stance by citing Jesus Christ's instruction in John chapter four, where Christ tells the Samaritan woman that true worshippers must worship the Father in spirit and truth. Because Jesus repeatedly defines the Holy Spirit as the Spirit of Truth, Thiel argues that the Holy Spirit cannot author contradictory or false declarations. Thiel reminds listeners that even Pope Francis voiced strong skepticism in 2017 regarding the Medjugorje visions. Francis remarked that he preferred Mary as a loving mother rather than the head of a telegraph office who dispatches daily scheduled communications through seers. Thiel concurs with Francis's frank assessment that this visionary phenomenon does not represent the biblical mother of Jesus, making Rome's continued tolerance deeply problematic.
Historical Warnings and Catholic Clerical Resistance
Thiel reviews how the Worldwide Church of God warned about Medjugorje as early as 1987. Back then, church publications documented how six Bosnian youths claimed daily visits from an apparition calling herself the Queen of Peace, who allegedly disclosed secrets about humanity's future. Thiel notes that although the apparition originally claimed encounters would last merely three days, messages have persisted for decades. Labeling the phenomenon demonic, Thiel explains that notable Roman Catholic authorities historically resisted the Bosnian shrine. In 1990, local Bishop Monsignor Pavao Žanić stated that detailing the falsehoods surrounding Medjugorje would require two hundred pages. Furthermore, in 1985 Cardinal Joseph Ratzinger, who later became Pope Benedict the Sixteenth, banned pilgrimages to the site. In 2013, the Apostolic Nunciature to the United States instructed clergy and lay members not to participate in events treating the visions as credible. Thiel emphasizes that despite official bans, seers amassed personal fortunes from gullible pilgrims.
Historical Precedents and the Beast's Rise
Dupuis asks Dr. Thiel to explain why non-Catholics should care about Marian apparitions. Thiel warns that supernatural visions played a pivotal historical role in spreading false religion throughout the centuries. Marian apparitions helped Greco-Roman churches displace original apostolic congregations across Asia Minor and medieval Europe. Later apparitions in Mexico and Russia successfully consolidated Roman Catholic power across Latin America and promoted icon veneration among Orthodox believers. Thiel cautions that Satan actively cultivates interest in female apparitions globally, which will eventually facilitate the rise of the prophesied end-time beast power. Quoting Matthew chapter twenty-four, Thiel emphasizes Jesus's warning that widespread deception would deceive almost everyone if possible. Thiel observes that the popularity of Medjugorje demonstrates how readily humanity embraces emotional experiences and sensory miracles over scriptural truth. When future apparitions perform dramatic wonders, billions who lack biblical grounding will willingly submit to prophetic deception.
Biblical Warnings Against Lying Wonders
Dupuis asks if scripture specifically addresses female apparitions and supernatural phenomena. Thiel cites Isaiah chapter forty-seven from the Douay-Rheims translation, where God condemns the virgin daughter of Babylon who boasts that she is the lady of kingdoms. Thiel connects this Old Testament prophecy to Revelation chapter eighteen, which foretells the complete destruction of Babylon for deceiving nations with sorceries. Thiel then reads from Second Thessalonians chapter two, reminding listeners that the coming of the lawless one operates according to Satan's power through signs and lying wonders. Scripture warns that God sends strong delusion upon those who refuse the love of the truth. Thiel explains that weeping statues and apparitions serve an ecumenical agenda, paving the way for deceptive unity under the beast. He urges believers to reject emotional signs and adhere strictly to biblical truth. Dupuis concludes the broadcast by inviting listeners to explore additional literature at biblenewsprophecy.net.
